Navigating Short-Term Rental Financing: A Guide for Success

Navigating Short-Term Rental Financing: A Guide for Success

Presented by Easy Street Capital. Read our editorial guidelines for more information.

Short-term rentals remain a red-hot area of real estate investing in 2023. Despite occasional market volatility and saturation in certain regions, savvy short-term rental investors are thriving, expanding, and scaling their businesses.

So, what sets successful short-term rental (STR) investors apart from those facing a personal portfolio “Airbnbust”? The answer is simple: Success in STR investing hinges on a professional approach. This means meticulously orchestrating all the components for success in the STR real estate market.

A professional approach involves treating your STR investments as a business. This includes utilizing pricing engines, hiring top-notch management or implementing advanced automated systems, building strong relationships with the right professionals (agents, cleaners, handymen, accountants), and perhaps most crucially, mastering financing. Skillfully managing each of these elements is often the key to both success and scalability, allowing investors to concentrate on the most valuable task—identifying and closing deals.

Short-Term Rental Loan Options

Understanding the financing aspect of STR investing can mean the difference between swift wealth accumulation and financial struggle. Even minor differences in loan terms can lead to vastly different returns on capital, the pace of portfolio expansion, and whether you experience positive cash flow or losses.

For most individuals seeking to build a portfolio of short-term rentals, leveraging borrowed funds (effectively) is a necessity, as many investors lack sufficient cash to purchase properties outright.

It’s worth noting that Airbnb is just 15 years old, established in August 2008 during the real estate mortgage crisis. This burgeoning short-term rental industry has developed alongside significant changes in the mortgage lending business. These changes include the enactment of the Dodd-Frank Act in 2010, which introduced “qualified mortgage” rules that raised mortgage standards across the industry.

Additionally, the rise of nonbank “non-QM” lenders in recent years introduced Debt Service Coverage Ratio (DSCR) loans, specifically designed for investment properties and featuring rigorous underwriting and documentation standards—qualities lacking in the infamous NINJA loans (poorly underwritten loans to often unqualified borrowers) that contributed to the 2008 mortgage crisis.

Summer 2023 Short-Term Rental Landscape

In the middle of 2023, short-term rental investors are presented with various financing options. As many traditional banks reduce lending due to high interest rates, regulatory ambiguity, and concerns about regional credit crunches, those seeking STR loans primarily have three choices:

1. Conventional loans: These are standard investment property loans that adhere to agency (Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac) guidelines. Conventional loans are typically underwritten based on the borrower’s personal income and debt-to-income ratio (DTI).
2. Second home loans: Also known as vacation home loans, this subset of conventional loans is popular for their lower minimum down payment (10%).
3. DSCR loans: Originated by private lenders, DSCR loans are designed for investment properties. They focus on property cash flow potential and offer flexibility in underwriting.

Although DSCR loans often carry slightly higher rates and fees than the previous two options, they are favored by professional STR investors due to their flexibility. Short-term rentals are a growing and evolving sector of real estate, and private lenders can adapt more swiftly than conventional lenders tied to agency guidelines.

Comparing DSCR Loans to Other Options

When seeking financing, it’s crucial to consider all available options. Here’s how DSCR loans compare to other common loan choices:

Short-term rental loans: Conventional vs. DSCR

Conventional loans often have lower rates, typically about 0.75% to 1% lower than DSCR loans. However, they come with certain drawbacks, such as stringent DTI requirements, tax return documentation, limitations on borrowing in an LLC, and restrictions on the number of loans and loan amounts.

On the other hand, DSCR loans focus primarily on property cash flow potential and do not consider DTI or personal income. These loans offer more flexibility and adaptability to changing market conditions.

Short-term rental loans: Second home loans vs. DSCR

Second home loans require a lower down payment (10%), making them attractive to some investors. However, they come with significant limitations, including restrictions on the number of days the property can be rented (maximum 180 days per year), lack of property management company usage, and restrictions on property types and locations.

DSCR loans, while slightly more expensive, are generally the preferred choice for financing short-term rentals due to their flexibility and investor-friendly terms.

Short-Term Rental DSCR Loans: Different Lenders, Different Guidelines

Not all DSCR lenders are created equal, especially when it comes to short-term rentals. While many DSCR lenders do not lend on STR properties, those that do vary in their approach. Some lenders require properties to qualify as long-term rentals or demand 12 months of documented STR platform history. In contrast, others fully embrace short-term rentals, underwriting with innovative tools like revenue projections from leading data sources and financing multiunit STR properties.

Conclusion

Investing in short-term rentals can be rewarding yet challenging. As the industry continues to grow, staying informed about evolving lending options is essential. With the right financing strategy, you can position yourself for success and navigate the ever-changing landscape of short-term rental investing.